Carthage

About

Carthage is a charming town that looks like it came straight out of a Thomas Kincade painting. It lies to the south of Fort Drum and has gracious homes from the 1800s and early 1900s. This village offers a small-town vibe, spacious lots, and easy access to post. Residents invest time and effort in their properties, and the pride of ownership shows. Carthage also offers the opportunity for more space, with some homes just outside of the village featuring lots with two or more acres.

Carthage can be a mix of two worlds, with local working class families and farmers living alongside military families. There is a bit of shopping (including a Price Chopper and an Aldi) in town, as well as several eateries. From May through October, the town hosts the Carthage Farmers Market on Fridays, with local produce, baked goods, and craft items for sale.

Families are drawn to this quintessential northern New York town for the schools. The elementary schools in Carthage have a particularly good reputation, and the Carthage district is one of two that serves the students living on Fort Drum. Carthage residents also enjoy Turning Point Park, a waterfront park, and Carthage Park, which offers a large wooden playground, a skateboard park, and trails.

Neighbors

Carthage is popular with service members and there is a significant military presence in town. Carthage Area Hospital draws those working in the healthcare sector to town.

Neighborhood Feel

Many homes in Carthage were built in the 19th century and the early part of the 20th century. You can find large Victorians, Cape Cods, and some smaller mid-century family homes. There are also a good number of townhomes and apartments in town.

PCS’ing to Fort Drum?

Don’t go at it alone

AgentHero

Buy or Sell a Home

Scouts

Help on the Ground

Find A Rental

Rent Smart

Please let us know a little about your needs, and we’ll connect you with an AgentHero or Scout prepared to help you.
No spam, no hassles, total privacy guaranteed.

Neighborhood Location

Commute
Fort Drum – Gas Alley Gate (Rt. 26)
Drive Time to Gate
15 to 25* minutes
By Transit
N/A

Neighborhood Info

Carthage - Fort Drum, NY - gomillie.com

Points of Interest

Carthage Park

Carthage Farmer’s Market

Ryders Edge Skate Park

Big Plus

Carthage schools are well-regarded and the area is popular with families looking to reside in the school district.  

This classic North Country village has an appealing small town vibe.

Carthage is convenient to Fort Drum without feeling like you are still on post.

Things to Consider

Carthage is sprawling, and your commute might be longer than expected if you find yourself in the far reaches of town.

There isn’t a lot of nightlife in this small, quiet town.

How’s the Market?

The median home value for a single family home in Carthage is $128,00 according to the Zillow Home Value Index.

According to Zillow’s Rental Index, the median rental rate for single family rentals in Carthage is $1,158.

Single family homes in Carthage range from 959 to 3,050 square feet. The average home measures about 1,663 square feet.

School Scoop

Public schools in Carthage are in Carthage Central School District, which has an overall rating of 5. There are three schools in Carthage, including West Carthage Elementary School, rated a 7 according to Greatschools.org.

Carthage Central School District is one of the two districts that serve children living on Fort Drum. The school district offers Student Online Achievement Resources (SOAR), a program designed specifically for military children that assists families with school transitions by offering assessments and tutorials design to help familiarize students with school standards in a new location.  

Augustine Academy is a private option for families in Carthage.

Highlighted Areas

Forest Hills apartments

Buckley Building apartments